Why Casinos Cannot Be Ranked by Payout Rate
By Wes Burns · Published 20 Jun 2015 · Updated 27 Oct 2026
What a Return Figure Is Attached To
Under the Gambling Commission's remote gambling and software technical standards, a document last updated on 7 May 2024, the information a player must be given is attached to a game and not to a site. The aim of RTS 3 is “To enable customers to make informed decisions about whether to gamble based on their chances of winning, the way the game, lottery or event works, the prizes or payouts on offer and the current state of multi-state games or events.”, and among the acceptable ways of describing the likelihood of winning the guidance lists “the average theoretical return to player percentage.” The Commission's live return to player monitoring guidance, last updated on 29 January 2025, defines that figure: “This is the designed return to player percentage of the game, it will also be the advertised RTP of the game as displayed in the player facing rules, as per RTS 3C.”
Where it comes from is the game's own maths. The Commission's testing annex states that “Collectively the game rules determine the overall game RTP.” A change to those rules is a regulated event: “A major update, which will require external retesting by an approved test house, is any software change which may affect the fairness of a game.” Different releases of the same title are treated as distinct for monitoring, because “Remote games are often released separately on different platforms or channels (for example, mobile, flash, download).” and “For example, errors that only exist in the mobile version of the game might be less visible if monitoring aggregates all markets and channels into one calculation.” A return figure is therefore a property of one game and of the build of it that was tested and released.
What a Return Figure Looks Like in Money
What the percentage is measured against is turnover rather than the sum a player puts in, and the Commission's monitoring guidance defines turnover as “The total of all stakes made on the game, this will include reinvested winnings awarded during play.” A pound that is won and staked again is therefore counted again. Depositing £100 at a game with a 95% return does not mean £95 comes back out at the end of a session. The return figure has nothing to do with depositing against cashing out.
A £1 stake on a slot with a 95% return carries an expected loss of £0.05 per spin over the long run. That is a long-run average and nothing more: a 95% return does not mean exactly 5% of a spin’s stake is lost on that spin. It is an average across a large number of plays.
Consider a thought experiment. A billion people each walk into a casino, are handed £1, and each spends it on a single spin of a slot with a 95% return.
Tally every one of those players’ wins and losses. Some have won large jackpots, some have lost a little, some have won a little, and some have lost the whole £1. Add the results up and average them out, and the average loss is £0.05 per player.
What that average describes is the expected return on a single wager, nothing more. It is entirely possible to lose a whole balance in one session without catching a significant win. All a return figure gives a player is a general average of the long-term expectation on that game.
Why a Single Site-Wide Number Does Not Compare Anything
A casino lobby holds games whose returns are set separately, and several of its categories do not reduce to a single designed figure at all. For games involving skill, the Commission's RTS 3 guidance says a return percentage “should be calculated using either the auto-play strategy or a standard/published strategy” — so the figure depends on an assumed way of playing. For virtual sports, “In a similar way to skill games virtual sports returns will mostly depend on the player choices and so there won’t be a single theoretical RTP.” Live tables are not RNG products at all: “Live dealers use physical equipment (such as roulette wheels and decks of cards) to determine the results and there are a range of other integrity measures that surround such provision.” And progressive games have to be measured apart from their jackpot component, where “Given jackpots tend to be infrequent and large they will have high volatility ratings, therefore measuring their RTP might not be feasible.” Averaging across all of that produces a number whose value depends on which games the measured players happened to choose.
The Commission's own instruction on aggregation points the same way: “Monitoring must not be so aggregated that it hides errors at a lower level.”, and “Volatility is vital to these calculations regardless of volume of play and will be a key parameter to include when establishing the allowable tolerance for each game.” A short measurement is not a measurement: “Measuring a game with only a small amount of play will be pointless as the tolerance will be too large for meaningful results.” For one game designed at 91.68% with a volatility of 5.6, the Commission's table gives the scale — “So if 400,000 games had been played to accrue turnover and win figures of the example then the allowable tolerance will be 1.75 above or below 91.68.”, meaning “The game could return between 89.93% and 93.43% and still be considered to be performing as expected.”
What Regulators Publish About Returns
In Great Britain the published figures are revenue, not payout rates. The Gambling Commission's industry statistics annual report for April 2025 to March 2026, published on 17 September 2026, “provides an overview of Gross Gambling Yield (GGY) made by licensed gambling operators from GB gambling customers for each customer-facing sector, along with the numbers of licensed operators and premises.”, and it is “based on data reported to us by the operators we license and regulate.” Within that, “online casino games dominate the sector, generating £5.7 billion in GGY, £4.8 billion of which was from slots games”. The same relationship is defined at game level in the monitoring guidance: “The GGY of a game will be the turnover minus win.”
Two United States regulators publish on a comparable basis. The Nevada Gaming Control Board states that “The Monthly Revenue Report is a summary of revenue information for nonrestricted gaming activity.”, and that “Each report reflects 1-month, 3-month, and 12-month data.” The Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board states that it “is dedicated to ensuring the public is informed about the gross revenue and tax revenue generated across all gaming markets regulated by the Board.”, with reports “available in both PDF and Excel formats and can be accessed by selecting a state fiscal year and the desired type of gaming.” These are measures of operator revenue over a period. None of them is a return to player figure that a player can compare between casinos, and this page therefore does not rank casinos by payout rate.
Where a Player Can Compare
The comparison the Commission's rules actually enable is game by game, before a stake is placed. “An explanation of the applicable rules must be easily available to the customer before they commit to gamble.”, and “For each virtual event, game (including bingo), or lottery, content describing the potential prizes and payouts or the means by which these are calculated or determined must be easily available before the customer commits to gamble.” In practice, “Information should be made available about the amounts that customers may potentially win, for example in the form of pay-tables, or by showing the odds paid for particular outcomes.”
A Published Percentage Is Not a Record of Conduct
A payout figure says nothing about how an operator treats its customers, and the regulator's enforcement record is separate from it. On 28 March 2023 the Commission announced that “Three gambling businesses owned by William Hill Group will pay a total of £19.2 million for social responsibility and anti-money laundering failures.” — “WHG (International) Limited, which runs williamhill.com, will pay £12.5 million, Mr Green Limited, which runs mrgreen.com, will pay £3.7 million and William Hill Organization Limited, which operates 1,344 gambling premises across Britain, will pay £3 million.” On 1 March 2022 the Commission announced that “An online gambling business will pay a £9.4m fine after a Gambling Commission investigation revealed social responsibility and money laundering failings.”, naming the operator: “888 UK Limited, which operates 78 websites including 888.com, has also received an official warning and will undergo extensive independent auditing.”
